It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Full Coverage Anti-Aging Waterproof Concealer, Tan Natural, 0.40 fl oz/12 mL

Thanks for your question. The two shades were reviewed in different years and have different ingredient lists. The shade you’re looking at now was rated in 2024, while Rich (35.5) was rated in 2022 with a different formulation. Because the ingredients don’t match, the safety ratings don’t match either.

If you’d like, you can compare the ingredient lists for both shades to see exactly what changed.